Introduction

Litigation funding has emerged as a significant financial tool for plaintiffs in various types of legal disputes, including patent litigation. This practice involves third-party funders providing financial support to plaintiffs in exchange for a share of the settlement or judgment. While litigation funding has its critics, it offers several advantages to patent plaintiffs, particularly in leveling the playing field against well-funded defendants, enhancing access to justice, and allowing plaintiffs to focus on innovation. This essay explores these advantages and discusses why litigation funding can be beneficial for patent plaintiffs.

Leveling the Playing Field

Patent litigation is outrageously expensive and can be financially devastating for individual inventors or small companies. Defendants in patent cases are often large corporations with substantial resources at their disposal. These corporations can afford prolonged legal battles, which can be financially debilitating for less-resourced plaintiffs. In fact, it is not an uncommon defense tactic to drive up the costs of litigation in an attempt to outlast a patent plaintiff. Litigation funding helps level the playing field by providing the financial resources necessary to sustain a legal challenge against well-funded opponents.

1. Financial Parity: Litigation funding allows patent plaintiffs to hire top-tier legal representation and expert witnesses, which they might not afford otherwise. This financial support ensures that plaintiffs can present a robust case, increasing their chances of success.
2. Risk Mitigation: For plaintiffs, the financial risk associated with losing a patent lawsuit can be catastrophic. Litigation funding mitigates this risk by absorbing the costs if the case is unsuccessful. This non-recourse nature of funding is particularly appealing as it enables plaintiffs to pursue their claims without the fear of financial ruin.

Litigation Funders take Many Forms

In many cases, it is a client's law firm that acts as the litigation funder, whether through the resources of the law firm or by raising capital outside the firm.  In other cases, a third party acts independently of the law firm, providing capital to cover case expenses and costs.  In other cases, it may be a hybrid approach where a law firm works with a  third party who helps to raise the funds.

Enhancing Access to Justice

Access to justice is a fundamental principle of the American system, yet many potential litigants are unable to pursue their claims due to financial constraints. Litigation funding addresses this issue by providing the necessary resources for plaintiffs to have their day in court.  Litigation funding provides access to the courthouse to many who otherwise would not be able to afford that access.

1. Empowering Innovators: Many patent plaintiffs are individual inventors or small startups with limited financial means. Litigation funding empowers these innovators by enabling them to protect their intellectual property rights, which are often their most valuable and sometimes only remaining assets.
2. Promoting Fairness: By enabling plaintiffs to pursue valid claims, litigation funding ensures that justice is not only accessible to those with deep pockets. This promotes fairness in the legal system and ensures that defendants are held accountable for patent infringement.
3. Encouraging Settlements: The presence of litigation funding can encourage defendants to settle cases earlier, knowing that the plaintiff has the financial backing to pursue the case to trial. This can lead to more efficient resolutions and reduce the burden on the court system.

Supporting Innovation and Economic Growth

Patent litigation funding not only benefits individual plaintiffs but also has broader implications for fostering innovation and economic growth.

1. Protecting Intellectual Property: Intellectual property rights are crucial for encouraging innovation. When inventors and companies know that they can protect their patents through litigation funding, they are more likely to invest in research and development. This protection fosters an environment of innovation, which is vital for technological advancement and economic growth.
2. Encouraging Investment: By ensuring that patent holders can enforce their rights, litigation funding makes the patent system more reliable. This reliability encourages investment in technology and innovation, as investors are assured that their investments can be protected legally.
3. Promoting Competitive Markets: By enabling small players to challenge larger corporations, litigation funding helps maintain competitive markets. This competition can lead to better products and services, benefiting consumers and the economy as a whole.

Addressing Criticism of Litigation Funding

While litigation funding offers numerous advantages to patent plaintiffs, it is not without its critics. Opponents argue that it can lead to frivolous lawsuits and that funders may exert undue control over litigation. However, these concerns can be mitigated through regulation and transparency.

1. Regulation and Oversight: Implementing regulations that require disclosure of litigation funding agreements can address concerns about transparency and control. Such regulations can ensure that funders do not exert undue influence over litigation decisions.
2. Preventing Frivolous Lawsuits: Litigation funders typically conduct thorough due diligence before investing in a case, as their returns depend on the success of the litigation. This vetting process naturally weeds out frivolous claims, as funders are unlikely to invest in cases with little chance of success.

Conclusion

Litigation funding provides a crucial financial lifeline for patent plaintiffs, enabling them to protect their intellectual property rights and pursue justice. By leveling the playing field, enhancing access to justice, and supporting innovation, litigation funding plays a pivotal role in the legal and economic landscape. While there are valid concerns regarding its use, appropriate regulation and transparency can address these issues, ensuring that litigation funding remains a valuable tool for patent plaintiffs. As the legal environment continues to evolve, litigation funding is likely to become an increasingly important part of the process.

Want to keep up with more content like this? Subscribe here to our new newsletter.

Ramey LLP is a full-service litigation law firm working with a national client base from our Houston, Texas office. We are dedicated to enhancing client results through efficient practice management, innovative technologies and the use of skilled professionals.